Overcome Imposter Syndrome: Leadership Coach Strategies

Me resting in Labadee, Haiti with ocean and mountains beyond me with Andy Stanley quote about inner self.

Have you ever walked into a room and wondered, "What am I doing here, and how long until they figure out I’m in way over my head?" That creeping sense of self-doubt has a name: Imposter Syndrome. It’s the nagging inner voice that says you don’t measure up, despite a track record of real accomplishments. It tells you that your that success was luck, your contributions don’t count, and sooner or later, people will see you for who you really are: not enough.

Sound familiar? You’re not alone. Imposter syndrome isn’t a disease or defect. It’s a common experience, especially for ambitious, growth-minded professionals. (Even Serena Williams and Tom Hanks have spoken publicly about feeling it!) The great news is you can flip the script. When you start noticing self-doubt creeping in, you can test it for truth, change the narrative, and prepare better for what’s ahead.

As a leadership coach, I see imposterism surface most often when my clients are in the midst of change, taking on a new role, joining a new team, facing fresh expectations, or daring to go after something bigger or different. In our work together, they learn to spot the signs, reframe the thinking, and use it as fuel for intentional growth.

In this blog post, I identify six profiles of how Imposter Syndrome often shows up in the workplace, along with strategies to reframe and grow beyond it. Which profile resonates with you most?

Profile 1: Overpreparation or Procrastination.

Spot it: You’ve been selected for a high-visibility project, but instead of celebrating, you assume leadership made a mistake. You grind out long days to avoid being "found out."

Reframe it: Ask how the team was chosen and what specific strengths they saw in you. Understanding their confidence in you helps counter your inner critic.

Grow from it: Use the project to deepen key relationships, learn new skills, expand your visibility, and later share with others the value you contributed and gained.

Profile 2: Perfectionism

Spot it: A colleague compliments your work, and you immediately downplay it. You explain the few things that didn’t go perfectly, rather than what worked well.

Reframe it: Practice saying a simple “thank you.” Then ask, “What was most helpful for you?” to open dialogue and shift from judgment to curiosity.

Grow from it: Gather feedback and reflect holistically on what worked well and what didn’t. Use the insights moving forward to grow instead of chasing flawlessness.

Profile 3: Martyrdom

Spot it: Layoffs and resignations have left your team short-staffed. You try to do it all, including tasks below your role, and begin to wonder if this is all you’re good for.

Reframe it: Instead of doing everything, bring your team together to identify critical needs, clarify roles, and pace the work equitably.

Grow from it: Lead through the transition. Show loyalty by helping redesign how work gets done rather than trying to carry it all alone.

Profile 4: Autopilot

Spot it: Your smarts have allowed you to coast through tasks with ease for years. Now you’re facing a real challenge, and you’re paralyzed, unsure how to solve it.

Reframe it: This isn’t proof you don’t belong. It’s an opportunity to balance your ideas with input from others.

Grow from it: Seek out stretch assignments and outside perspectives regularly. Doing so builds humble confidence, a broader skillset, and greater alignment with your team.

Profile 5: Long-winded

Spot it: Tension is high in a meeting. You rattle off explanations to appease your boss, only to feel dismissed or misunderstood.

Reframe it: You showed courage by speaking up and demonstrated a strong understanding of the issues (even under pressure).

Grow from it: Prepare thoughtfully, speak purposefully, and invite other voices. Steady, intentional contribution will build your influence over time.

Profile 6: Heads down

Spot it: Your manager’s tone has changed. Without explanation, you assume you’ve disappointed them and quietly retreat into your work.

Reframe it: Others' behavior often reflects their own struggles, not your performance. Choose to stay visible and connected.

Grow from it: Focus on how you can best support the team’s goals. Stay informed, stay engaged, and trust that your presence matters.

Imposter Syndrome thrives in silence. When you start noticing how self-doubt shows up in your story, you can respond with truth, self-compassion, and intention. You are not perfect, none of us are, but you are enough. Remind yourself of your successes and achievements that have led you to this space and claim it. Don’t believe the imposter...you belong right where you are.

As a leadership coach, I coach growth-minded professionals to lead well, get recognized, and thrive. I publish a monthly newsletter and blog post and invite you to subscribe under my Contacts page.

Let's Chat!